Stamped vs Judge.me vs Trustyy: Which Shopify Review App Is Right for You?

Merchants comparing stamped vs judge.me are usually weighing budget simplicity against mid-market power. Judge.me wins on price; Stamped.io wins on depth. But there's a third option worth knowing about before you commit.

---

Quick Verdict

App	Best for	Starting price
Judge.me	Shopify stores wanting unlimited reviews at $0–$15/mo flat	Free / $15/mo
Stamped.io	Mid-market brands needing NPS, loyalty, and UGC at scale	From $23/mo (order-based)
Trustyy	New and growing stores wanting automation without the price tag	Free

---

Judge.me - The Budget-Friendly Workhorse

Judge.me is the most widely adopted review app on Shopify. If you're looking for a proven shopify review app with a generous free tier, it's the obvious starting point.

What it does well

• Unlimited review requests on the free plan - no order caps, no artificial limits.

• Flat $15/mo Awesome plan - one price regardless of order volume, which is rare in this category.

• Massive social proof - 44,000+ reviews on the Shopify App Store, 748K+ stores installed.

Where it falls short

• Key integrations are paywalled - Klaviyo, Google Shopping, SMS, and AI tools are all locked behind the Awesome plan.

• Widget customisation is limited on the free tier - you can't edit CSS or match your brand fully without upgrading.

• The dashboard can feel complex for merchants who just want to collect and display reviews without configuring workflows.

Judge.me pricing

Forever Free: Unlimited review requests, photo and video reviews, basic widgets.

Awesome - $15/mo flat: Adds Klaviyo, Google Shopping, SMS, AI-powered features, custom email domain, and full widget CSS control.

---

Stamped.io - The Mid-Market Platform

Stamped.io is less a review app and more a post-purchase marketing suite. If you're comparing stamped.io vs judge.me because you need more than just reviews, Stamped is built for that.

What it does well

• NPS surveys, loyalty programmes, and in-email review submission - all native, no third-party tools needed.

• Google Product Ratings and Google Seller Ratings - built into the Reviews plan, useful for paid search campaigns.

• Video UGC and advanced automation - strong for brands running high order volumes with complex post-purchase flows.

Where it falls short

• No free plan and no free trial - you're committing from day one.

• Order-based pricing scales steeply - $23/mo for 200 orders, $99/mo for 1,000 orders, $199/mo for 5,000 orders. Volume growth means bill growth.

• Overkill for most small stores - if you only need review collection and display, you're paying for features you won't use.

Stamped.io pricing

Plan	Price	Order limit
Basic	$23/mo	200 orders/mo
Growth	$99/mo	1,000 orders/mo
Business	$199/mo	5,000 orders/mo
Loyalty (add-on)	$299/mo	Separate product

No free plan. No free trial. Loyalty is a separate purchase on top of the Reviews plan.

---

Trustyy - The Free Alternative Worth Considering

Trustyy is a newer entrant - 300+ stores, rated 4.8/5 on the Shopify App Store - built specifically for merchants who find judge.me too limited on the free tier and Stamped too expensive to justify. It's a credible judge.me alternative and a lean yotpo alternative for stores that don't need enterprise features.

What it does well

• Fully free core product - automated review requests, 7 customisable widgets, AI-powered spam filter, bulk review management, and one-click import from other apps. No order caps.

• Zero technical setup - install, connect, and your first review request goes out automatically after purchase.

• AI features included at no cost - spam filtering and auto-publish moderation work out of the box, no upgrade required.

Where it falls short

• Smaller install base - it's a newer app, so the community and third-party resources are less mature than Judge.me's.

• Klaviyo and Google Shopping integrations are coming soon - not live yet, so if those are non-negotiable today, factor that in.

Trustyy pricing

Free - all core features included. No order caps, no transaction fees, no hidden upgrade wall.

---

Side-by-Side Comparison

Feature	Judge.me Free	Judge.me Awesome	Stamped Basic	Trustyy
Automated review requests	✅	✅	✅	✅
Photo & video reviews	✅	✅	✅	✅
Spam filter / auto-publish	⚠️ Basic	✅ AI-powered	✅	✅ AI-powered
Customisable widgets	⚠️ Limited	✅ Full CSS	✅	✅
Klaviyo integration	❌	✅	✅	🔜 Soon
Google Shopping	❌	✅	✅ ($199/mo plan)	🔜 Soon
NPS surveys	❌	❌	✅	❌
Starting price	Free	$15/mo	$23/mo	Free

---

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose Judge.me if you want the most proven free review app on Shopify with a clear, affordable upgrade path. The $15/mo Awesome plan is genuinely good value once you need Klaviyo or Google Shopping - and 748K+ stores can't be wrong about the basics.

Choose Stamped.io if you're a mid-market brand that needs NPS surveys, a loyalty programme, and Google Product Ratings bundled into one platform - and you can justify spending $100–$200/mo. For stores at that scale, the consolidated toolset can replace several separate subscriptions. In the judge.me vs stamped debate at that budget level, Stamped wins on depth.

Choose Trustyy if you're a new or growing store that wants full review automation and clean, customisable widgets for free - and doesn't yet need Klaviyo or Google Shopping. It's the best review app for shopify merchants who want to move fast without a monthly commitment, and it's a straightforward upgrade path once those integrations go live.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

---

If you're leaning toward Trustyy, you can install it free from the Shopify App Store - setup takes under 2 minutes. Install Trustyy Free →